A Portal
There are few other life events that shift our lens on life as much as having children. Becoming a parent doesn’t just change the logistics of our lives. It changes our understanding and beliefs about the world, our existing relationship dynamics, our feelings about the past and the future, and, most importantly, our sense of identity itself.
The experience of parenthood often also exposes us to parts of ourselves we may have not had access to, or may have not even existed before having children. For many, the intense and unexpected changes and paradigm shifts of life and identity, alongside all that we are required to balance, manage, and tolerate in our children’s early years, can bring to the surface unexpected, confusing, and sometimes distressing internal experiences and emotions.
When this occurs, many parents seek out support from a therapist. But it can be difficult to know what kind of therapy modality can help the most during this vulnerable time. In this article, I’ll expand on why the transition to parenthood can be so challenging, and introduce two distinct therapies, psychodynamic therapy and IFS (internal family systems) that can help us navigate this period with greater understanding, flexibility, and self-compassion.
Our usual MO
Whether or not we are aware of it, each one of us has developed a unique set of tools to manage the difficulties, anxieties, unpredictability, griefs, and drudgeries of life.
Most of us have techniques that are genuinely helpful. Humor, channeling our feelings into artistic or athletic pursuits, distracting ourselves by spending time with loved ones, can all be supportive ways to manage life’s difficulties. Some of our coping mechanisms, like scrolling social media, googling answers to medical anxieties, or shopping, are healthy enough in moderation, but can become detrimental when we feel that we need to do them in order to feel ok.
And some things that society tends to celebrate, such as pleasing people, perfectionism, exercising to excess, or working long hours and always staying busy, may actually, upon closer investigation, be hurting our relationship to ourselves and loved ones.
In psychodynamic therapy, these strategies are often understood as defenses: ways of managing feelings, thoughts, and conflicts that may be difficult to tolerate consciously. In IFS, manager parts are proactive protectors. They try to head off discomfort by staying busy, hyperfocusing on achievement, pushing down our own feelings to side-step conflict, and avoiding distressing situations.
It’s important to emphasize that our defenses or protective mechanisms aren’t inherently bad. In fact, we need to have ways to armor ourselves from feeling the overwhelm and hardships of life. And in many cases they may have helped us feel safe, hold on to important relationships, meet expectations, or navigate environments in which expressing certain feelings was risky.
Often, our defensive and protective strategies work remarkably well in helping us manage feelings of inadequacy, navigate relationship friction, and maintain a sense of competence in a world that can feel overwhelming.
Bringing a Baby Home
But bringing a baby home can throw a wrench into our protective and defensive systems. Babies don’t care about self- protection strategies. They know no boundaries, social cues, niceties. All they know is the task of survival and attachment. Their fear, hunger, overwhelm, have no filter, no mask of politeness, no transmutation into something more palatable. All of a sudden, you have a little creature who needs you - ALL of you - here, and now, and who has a powerful biological imperative to let you know. Time can feel as though it contracts, as you are forced to attend to this very moment - the crying, the diaper change, the bottle cleaning, the feeding, the bouncing or rocking, again and again and again. As most new parents would agree, to call this sudden change simply overwhelming would be an understatement.
The challenges don’t stop in infancy. Toddlers and young children bring their own demands: tantrums, boundary-setting, separation anxiety, conflicting parenting philosophies, and the ongoing challenges of helping a developing human manage big feelings they can’t understand or handle alone.
All of this unfolds against the backdrop of changing relationships, shifting identities, and, for many parents, significant sleep deprivation and hormonal changes.
The Elevator
A mentor of mine once shared an analogy that has stuck with me as I have navigated my own postpartum and early parenting journey. When we have a baby, we step onto an elevator that brings parts of us that we don’t have full access to, often young, vulnerable parts, down to the age that our own baby is. We relive, in a very visceral, embodied way, our own infant-hood, baby-hood, childhood, alongside our little ones. In having no option but to witness our child’s tempests and vicissitudes, we are also confronted with our own.
The reality is that the range, intensity, and frequency of children’s needs and feelings often elicit in us the very emotions we have spent a lifetime developing mechanisms to try to cope with, distract, or fix within ourselves. They can also bring up emotions or experiences we didn’t even know we had, ghosts of our own infancy or childhoods that only awaken upon entering parenthood. When the strategies that once helped us feel in control become less available, and we are visited by the shadows of a past we don’t always remember, we may find ourselves facing emotions and experiences we don't yet know how to understand or hold.
This doesn’t mean that every difficult parenting moment is a replay of our childhood, or that every strong reaction has a hidden origin. Sometimes we are simply exhausted, unsupported, overstimulated, or facing a genuinely difficult situation. But the transition to parenthood can make it harder to rely on familiar coping strategies, leaving us more exposed to feelings we may not yet know how to understand or hold.
Whether or not our experiences in early parenthood have ties to our pasts, or are more reflective of the current difficulties we are facing, the portal into parenthood can be beyond hard - sometimes, it can feel completely terrifying.
What Are Psychodynamic Therapy and Internal Family Systems, and How Can They Help?
Psychodynamic Therapy
A brief history and the research behind it
Psychodynamic therapy is a broad field over therapeutic approaches with over a century of evolving history. Though its history traces back to its often infamous, or at the very least, misunderstood originator, Sigmund Freud, whose early writings shaped the beginnings of psychoanalysis, the field has had hundreds, if not thousands, of other brilliant minds who have contributed to its decades of growth, refinements, and evolution. Attachment theory, arguably one of the most extensively researched and empirically supported theories in developmental psychology, is an arm of psychoanalytic theory, and stands on the shoulders of many other psychoanalytic theorists before it. Research shows psychodynamic therapy’s efficacy in treating a wide range of psychological challenges. Notably, psychodynamic therapy has shown to have lasting effects even after therapy ends.
How does it work?
At its core, psychodynamic therapy is interested in how our unconscious world influences how we show up in our lives and our relationships today. In psychodynamic therapy, a therapist is interested in how our unique temperament, our early experiences, and our culture combine to create a one of a kind constellation of thoughts, beliefs, feelings and behaviors in any given person. Psychodynamic therapists join with clients to explore their inner worlds, with the belief that understanding why we are the way we are can help us both find acceptance and compassion for ourselves, and offer us the opportunity to act out of agency rather than out of automatic reaction.
Psychodynamic therapists recognize that major life transitions can bring previously manageable or less conscious feelings into sharper focus, and that ways that we used to cope with feelings can become more difficult to sustain when our circumstances change.
Healing from Perfectionism
Take, for example, a woman whose own childhood was marked by parents with incredibly high standards for her. She may have learned to manage the pressure to be perfect by excelling academically and professionally. Achievement may become a source of pride, competence, and perhaps a way of feeling worthy of love and approval.
But after having a baby, she finds herself feeling intensely self-critical about her own parenting. She worries that she isn't doing enough, compares herself to other parents, and wonders whether she will ever be good enough for her child.
In psychodynamic therapy, we may explore whether the challenge of caring for a baby, which is in itself quite thankless and incredibly difficult, may leave her feeling inadequate. Her baby's needs, which cannot be met perfectly or anticipated completely, may expose her to feelings she has worked hard to avoid.
Therapy can help her explore what being a “good mother” means to her, whose expectations she may be carrying, and what she fears might happen if she makes a mistake. Over time, she may begin to distinguish between the expectations she “inherited” and the values she genuinely wants to bring to parenting.
She can learn that making mistakes does not make her inadequate, that uncertainty is an inevitable part of caregiving, and that her worth does not depend on getting everything right.
The relationship as a mechanism for change
The relationship is also an important part of psychodynamic therapy. But rather than the relationship just being a “safe place,” for change to occur, the therapist understands that what occurs in the relationship can offer important insight into the client’s world. In other words, the therapist attends to what she is feeling in the therapy room, and explores it as information about what the client is experiencing.
For example, an exhausted mother comes into therapy saying that she cannot allow anyone else to hold or care for her baby because no one can be trusted. The therapist may notice a tension in the therapy relationship, as well: while the client longs for support from the therapist, she also struggles to relinquish control. By gently sharing this observation, the therapist can help the client recognize the pattern and become curious about the beliefs and experiences underlying it.
This exchange can create an opportunity for the client to begin experiencing trust within the therapeutic relationship itself. She may discover, perhaps for the first time, that she can accept support without relinquishing her sense of safety or agency. Over time, this experience may make it easier for her to extend that trust beyond the therapy room and allow others in her life to help care for her and her baby.
Internal Family Systems Therapy
A brief history and the research behind it
Internal Family Systems therapy was developed by psychologist Richard Schwartz in the 1980s. Schwartz drew from his experience and expertise in Family Systems Theories and the understanding of family dynamics to conceptualize what goes on in an individual’s mind. Schwartz noticed that a person often has different “parts” of the self that often take on the same kind of personalities and dynamics of a family system, often representatives of individuals or relationships in their own family - hence the name Internal Family Systems.
He observed that people often describe competing desires, conflicting feelings, and distinct ways of responding to distress. For example, one “part” of a person might feel a need for control, while another, less evident part, might deeply long for support. Another might look for ways to quickly get rid of those vulnerable feelings that emerge by “zoning out” or disengaging. Rather than treating these experiences as evidence that something is wrong with the person, IFS offers a way to understand how these different responses may be attempting to meet different needs.
Because IFS is a newer therapy model than psychodynamic therapy, and its research base is considerably smaller. However, that is beginning to change as clinicians and clients alike are noting the positive benefits of this approach.
How does it work?
IFS works on the premise that, as noted before, we all have different parts of ourselves with unique personalities, desires, needs, and ways of being in the world.
In IFS, there are 3 broad categories of parts - proactive protectors or manager parts (as noted earlier), reactive protectors (also known as firefighters), and exiles.
Managers are proactive protectors. They attempt to prevent emotional pain by keeping us prepared, productive, responsible, or in control. A manager part might push us to maintain a perfectly clean home, become an expert on every aspect of infant development, or ensure that everyone around us is happy, even at the expense of our own well-being. These behaviors may help us feel secure, but they can also leave us exhausted, resentful, or disconnected from our own needs.
Firefighters are reactive protectors. They respond when difficult emotions become overwhelming or “break through” our usual defenses. The can also pop up when we are less resourced, and thus, less able to use our old coping mechanisms (for example, when we are very sleep deprived, or have little time for ourselves!) They often seek immediate relief through distractions, emotionally withdrawing, compulsive behaviors (such as shopping or disordered eating), substance use, or other ways of escaping distress.
Exiles are the vulnerable parts that carry our most painful feelings, such as shame, fear, loneliness, grief, or a sense of being unlovable. In the IFS model, these parts may be kept out of awareness because their feelings have seemed too difficult or threatening to experience. The term exile reflects the idea that these vulnerable experiences are often pushed out of conscious awareness in order so as to not overwhelm us with their intensity.
Let me offer a case example to illustrate how IFS might work in practice. A new father comes to therapy sharing that before having his baby, he has had a pretty good handle on his previously difficult relationship with substances. Through previous therapy, he has learned how to use healthier coping mechanisms, such as exercise and meditation, to settle his mind when he is feeling down. However, since having the baby, he hasn’t had the time or energy to engage in these. He has begun to notice bad feelings come up, and one beer to take the edge off has increased to three or four a night. Though he feels better in the moment, he is filled with shame the next day at having “fallen back” so far.
An IFS therapist might conceptualize this experience as a shift in the client's internal system in response to the demands of new parenthood. The manager parts that previously helped him regulate his emotions through exercise and meditation may no longer have the time or resources to do so effectively. As a result, difficult feelings or “exiles”, perhaps sadness, shame, or overwhelm, may become harder to manage. In response, a firefighter part may turn to alcohol as a more immediate way to “extinguish” this emotional distress. While drinking can offer temporary relief, it may also leave the client feeling more shame the following day, creating a cycle in which the firefighter's attempt to protect him inadvertently contributes to the very distress it is trying to get rid of.
An IFS therapist would not begin by trying to eliminate the part of him that drinks. Instead, the therapist might help him become curious about it. What does drinking offer him in those difficult evening hours? What happens inside him when the baby finally sleeps and he is left alone with his thoughts? What feelings might emerge if he did not drink? Does this part believe it is the only thing standing between him and an unbearable emotional experience? The point is not to excuse the drinking or minimize its consequences. It is to understand the purpose it serves while also taking the behavior and its risks seriously.
The Self
IFS also proposes that beneath these parts is an underlying Self: an intrinsic aspect of every person characterized by qualities such as curiosity, compassion, clarity, and confidence. In the case of the father above, the therapist would support the client in accessing “Self energy.” This might mean helping his protective parts discover that there are other ways to care for the pain beneath his distress than numbing it with alcohol, that also honor the difficulty of this particular time in life. Maybe he can’t go for his usual 4 mile run and 20 minute meditation, but could he take a walk with his baby and try to “sink into” the moment, by being more mindful of each step?
With time and trust, the therapist can also support the client in getting to know the vulnerable parts carrying this pain, exploring their histories and fears with compassion, and helping them release the burdens they have carried.
As these vulnerable parts begin to heal, the protective parts can learn that they no longer have to manage everything on their own. The Self, which IFS understands as an inherent capacity rather than something that must be created, can then take a more central role in leading the internal system.
How Psychodynamic Therapy and IFS Can Work Together to Foster Growth and Healing in Parenthood
Though there are some distinct differences between Psychodynamic therapy and Internal Family Systems, they have significant overlap as well. They both seek to transform a person's relationship with their inner experience. Both recognize that strategies that once helped someone survive or adapt can later constrain their lives. And both can help a person move from being unconsciously controlled by familiar patterns toward understanding them and responding with greater freedom.
Psychodynamic theory has a long, robust, history with lots of research proving its efficacy in providing clients with meaningful, lasting change. A clinician trained in psychodynamic theory and practice has a depth of understanding of the human experience based on over a hundred years of knowledge and (literally!) millions of hours of face to face interactions with people over time. However, the complexity of psychodynamic theory can sometimes feel hard to translate for clients, who want to understand what is going on in their own minds in a more relatable way.
While IFS is a much newer therapy with less evidence to back it up (although this is beginning to change), in my opinion, the beauty of it lies in how relatable it is to clients. The language of managers, firefighters, exiles and Self is easily understood, which can allow clients to quickly begin to have a more compassionate view on their difficulties, a necessary first step for change. This can be extremely important in the postpartum period and parenting, when everything feels so tender already.
Neither psychodynamic therapy, nor IFS, is inherently right for every parent, and they don't need to be used in isolation. The therapeutic relationship, the clinician's training, the client’s preferences, and the nature of the difficulties all matter.
Some clients may prefer the depth of exploration offered by psychodynamic therapy. Others may feel drawn to IFS's accessible language. Still others may benefit from a therapist who thoughtfully integrates elements of both approaches alongside other tailored treatments.
Ultimately, both can help us understand the histories and fears beneath our reactions, experience difficult feelings with less shame, and develop more room to feel, reflect, repair, and respond rather than relying on rigid strategies to keep distress at bay. This, can in turn, allow us to do the same with our own children’s intense and unpredictable feelings and reactions.
And perhaps most importantly, we can begin to realize that we don't have to do it alone.
If you are looking for support to go deeper in your understanding of yourself and your parenting, I invite you to reach out.
Connie Roberts is a licensed therapist (LCSW) in Colorado specializing in postpartum mental health, couples counseling, parenting, trauma, CPTSD, and body image. She utilizes psychodynamic therapy, somatic approaches, EMDR, and IFS/parts work. Connie accepts Kaiser Permanente insurance and offers sliding scale and out-of-pocket reimbursement options.